Have you ever thought
of how the world would be if you simply could not express yourself properly? I
am not talking only about having a lack of tools to express yourself, e.g.,
through art, like music, dance, painting or through other methods, like speech,
for instance. The true problem that I will present in this text lies in being
totally deficient in the expression of your own thoughts, emotions, and
desires. Can you imagine yourself being unable to say anything or to make a
gesture for what your heart wants to express? Even to the level that expression
becomes extinct because there is nothing left to express?
In George Orwell´s (in)famous novel “1984” occurs a problem with people
becoming expressionless through lack of words which I will present here. I will
also present an example that I noticed not long ago and is related to this
problem.
I want to point this problem out because heavy metal is a genre where artists
use a vast number of diverse words to express themselves. Without expression
there is no art or heavy metal whatsoever. This is also a general problem, not
only for heavy metal and art.
Syme
In Orwell´s “1984”,
there is a character called Syme. He is a minor character who works in the
Ministry of Truth who is working on the new edition of the Newspeak Dictionary.
The Ministry of Truth is the ministry of propaganda in the state of Oceania.
For instance, if they say that 2+2=5, then that is the truth. If they say that
the planet they live on is a cube, then it is a cube. The Ministry of Truth
serves the Party, better known as Ingsoc (English Socialism) in Newspeak, by
making up the truth and distributing it to the people all over the cities (in
this case, London). Newspeak is the language of Oceania which was created by
Ingsoc and its general purpose is to limit freedom of thought, the identity of
man and expression. As you can see, Oceania is the ultimate totalitarian state.
In one part of the book, Syme and the main character called Winston Smith, talk
about the new edition of Newspeak in which Syme has been working on. He said to
Winston that the key “ingredient” for making the new edition of Newspeak is to
reduce words as much as he can. In both senses, to reduce the number of words
to a minimum count and to reduce the staggering of words. For instance, you
would not have good, better and great, but rather good, plusgood and
plusplusgood. This is my example, it could be a part of Newspeak. For instance,
maybe in Newspeak, you would not have names for the spectrum of colors like we
do. Gray, green, red, yellow, purple and so on. You might have colorone,
colortwo, colorthree and so on.
This edition of Newspeak in which Syme has been working on has a sole purpose
to make people emotionless, expressionless and thoughtless for the benefit of
the Party. IT IS FORBIDDEN TO QUESTION
THE PARTY AND TO THINK THAT THE PARTY IS DOING SOMETHING WRONGLY. IT IS WRONGTHINK! A perfect recipe for making people fully
inhuman robots. I will now present an example of Newspeak:
English version: “Rectify big
brother´s speech in times issue March 17, 1984, which misreported Africa.
Newspeak version: “times 17.3.84 bb
speech malreported africa rectify”
Can you see the drastic difference between the two? The main goal of the Party is to get rid of thought crime and thought in general. The thing I will explain further, in context of heavy metal is, becoming expressionless and emotionless.
Real-life examples
I will now present two cases from our contemporary
world that are similar to reducing words from “1984”:
1.) THE INTERNET LANGUAGE
This is the first one I have noticed years ago. In this case, I am talking
about abbreviations that are used when commenting or texting on social media
like LOL, ROFL, LMAO, xD, brb and so on. The more wicked thing I have noticed
about it is when people text love messages or if they comment something online
furiously, their faces are still. They do not smile or have an angry face. They
just do it mechanically without any emotion whatsoever which could be a
potential threat to expression.
2.) FROM MOTHER AND FATHER TO PARENT 1 AND PARENT 2
This is another case I have noticed that has taken
place recently. So, when a baby is born, he/she will not have who is his/her
mother and father written on his birth paper, but rather parent 1 and parent 2.
This case has more problems than just the potential danger for expression, but
that is a subject for another time. This is a potential elimination of two
meanings: Mother, as a biological female parent, and father, as a biological
male parent. Hence, we will maybe, in the near future, just have the word
“parent”. The words (and their meanings) mother and father might be forgotten
in the near future. I especially see this as a threat to pagan metal bands that
use phrases like “Father Thunderer” or “Mother Earth”.
Summary
Heavy metal is a genre where expression of thought and
emotions is very important. When you see the lyrics which heavy metal bands
use, you will notice how many diverse words there are. They have a vast
vocabulary of words for expression. Words
are very important for expression! Just like the example I gave for pagan
metal bands, what would happen if the crucial words for expression just cease
to exist?It would be a disaster for
heavy metal or music in general to have words erased from our memory and
history. Can you actually imagine a world where you cannot express yourself as
you wish to? Or even worse, can you imagine a world where there is nothing left
to express? I hope the future is not Orwellian.